Bidding Wars and Why Investors Get Fooled By “Affordable” Markets

BiggerPockets Blog
Published: October 24, 2025
Pricing & Profitability

Summary

This article warns against bidding wars in real estate, highlighting that buyers often overpay and experience lower returns. It identifies markets prone to bidding wars and offers strategies for navigating them, emphasizing the importance of setting a maximum allowable offer (MAO) and knowing when to walk away.

Key Insights

  • The top 15 metros are expected to see price increases between August 2025 and August 2026, which will likely lead to bidding wars. Specific cities are listed that are expected to increase in value.
  • Homebuyers who win bidding wars overpay by an average of 8.2% and experience weaker returns over time.
  • Buyers who paid above asking price had higher default rates—1.9% above average.
  • Winners of bidding wars had annual returns 1.3% lower than comparable investors who stayed out of the fray.

Action Items

  • Be prepared to walk away from a bidding war if the property can't pay for itself (factoring in all expenses).
    Effort: low
    Impact: medium
  • Stick to your MAO (Maximum Allowable Offer) formula when evaluating a property.
    Effort: low
    Impact: medium
  • If considering a bidding war, consider waiving inspections and contingencies, giving your offer an expiration date, and remaining flexible on the closing date.
    Effort: low
    Impact: medium

Common Mistakes

  • Overpaying for a property in a bidding war can lead to lower returns, higher default rates and financial strain.

Related Videos

More from Pricing & Profitability

Beyond Self-Taught: Why RevProf Exists

This article explores the value of community and structured learning in revenue management, contrasting it with the common autodidactic approach. It emphasizes the limitations of self-directed learning and highlights the benefits of collaborative learning through RevProf, a platform designed for peer-driven discourse. It stresses the importance of challenging assumptions, refining judgment through dialogue, and building a community for professional growth.

about 10 hours ago78
New tool shows earning potential for World Cup Airbnb hosts - FOX4KC.com

This article discusses a new tool that helps Airbnb hosts assess their earning potential during the World Cup. It highlights the significance of the event in driving demand. The tool could be useful for hosts in cities hosting matches, helping them optimize pricing and maximize revenue.

about 11 hours ago75
FIFA World Cup 2026: Airbnb launches Host Earnings Calculator - Revista Merca2.0

Airbnb has launched a Host Earnings Calculator for the FIFA World Cup 2026, offering hosts a tool to estimate potential earnings. This tool is a response to the anticipated surge in demand during the event, potentially leading to increased occupancy and ADR. Hosts can utilize this to evaluate the profitability of their properties and optimize their pricing strategies for the event.

about 21 hours ago85

Curated by Learn STR by GoStudioM