Market Value vs. Rebuild Value: The Insurance Mistake That Costs Investors Thousands

BiggerPockets Blog
Published: December 18, 2025
Hosting Operations

Summary

This article from BiggerPockets discusses the importance of ensuring your short-term rental property insurance coverage is based on rebuild value, not market value. It explains how underinsuring your property can lead to significant out-of-pocket costs in case of a total loss. Hosts should review their insurance policies annually and report any property upgrades to ensure accurate coverage.

Key Insights

  • Carriers base coverage on rebuild value, not market value.
  • Market value and rebuild value have almost nothing to do with each other; market value reflects what a buyer might pay while rebuild value reflects what it would cost to reconstruct your property after a total loss.
  • When your insured value doesn’t match the true rebuild cost, you face two major problems: underinsuring and overinsuring.

Action Items

  • Review your policy every year to ensure coverage matches current rebuild costs, inflation hasn't pushed pricing beyond limits, and any recent claims, improvements, or occupancy changes are reflected.
    Effort: low
    Impact: medium
  • Report renovations, upgrades, and additions, as they directly affect rebuild value.
    Effort: low
    Impact: medium
  • Verify construction details for accuracy on your insurance policy’s declarations page.
    Effort: low
    Impact: medium

Tools & Resources

  • NREIG: NREIG is mentioned as an investor-focused insurance partner.

Common Mistakes

  • Underinsuring your property for its rebuild cost can leave you with the responsibility for the difference during a total loss.

Related Videos

More from Hosting Operations

MakeMyTrip and Ixigo partner with OpenAI to expand AI-powered travel tools

MakeMyTrip and Ixigo are partnering with OpenAI to integrate AI across their platforms. This collaboration aims to revolutionize the travel experience, supporting features like trip planning and booking. The integration is designed to personalize and convert inspiration into confirmed bookings, offering personalized outcomes at scale.

1 day agoIndia75
Airbnb Host Gets Odd Request From Guest—Then She Realizes: ‘Big Problem’ - Newsweek

An Airbnb host faced an unusual guest request, uncovering a potential 'big problem' impacting their operations. Details of the odd request and the subsequent realization about its negative consequences for the host's business model are presented. Further investigation revealed a significant issue that hosts should be aware of.

2 days ago75
Spring break plans? Spot these red flags so you don't get scammed on your stay - WDSU

This article from WDSU focuses on identifying potential scams related to spring break travel. It highlights red flags travelers should be aware of when booking accommodations, such as unrealistic prices or demands for unconventional payment methods. Knowing these potential pitfalls will help hosts and guests alike prevent fraud and ensure a safe and positive booking experience.

2 days ago75

Curated by Learn STR by GoStudioM