You’re Probably Comparing Your Performance to the Wrong Market

Rental Scale-Up
Published: December 19, 2025
Pricing & Profitability

Summary

This article emphasizes the importance of carefully defining your market when comparing your short-term rental performance. Instead of relying on a generic 'market' benchmark, hosts should create multiple market views based on factors like location, quality, and performance to make informed pricing and strategy decisions.

Key Insights

  • A useful comparison framework looks at the market from multiple angles: physical, qualitative, performance, and strategic.
  • Comparing your performance to 'the market' is often flawed because the market isn't well-defined. Depending on the definition, the same portfolio can appear to outperform, underperform, or stagnate.
  • The best operators build multiple views of the same market and don’t rely on a single comp set.

Action Items

  • Instead of asking "How do we compare to the market?", ask "Which version of the market should we compare ourselves to — and why?"
    Effort: low
    Impact: medium

Common Mistakes

  • Copying a price without context is copying an answer without seeing the question. Price matching without understanding constraints or performance of the competitor is risky and could lead to revenue leakage.

Related Videos

More from Pricing & Profitability

KC has ‘highest occupancy’ of World Cup cities. Is effort to add rentals working? - Kansas City Star

This article discusses Kansas City's high occupancy rates compared to other World Cup host cities, raising questions about the effectiveness of efforts to increase short-term rental availability. It implicitly touches on market trends and the impact of major events on the STR market. The article likely explores whether increased rental supply can meet demand while analyzing the city's approach to STRs.

about 19 hours agoKansas City, MO75
Best Mountain Towns Where Homes Deliver the Strongest Airbnb Returns - Realtor.com

Realtor.com's report on best mountain towns for Airbnb returns reveals key locations for STR investment. The analysis likely includes data on occupancy rates, ADR, and RevPAR to identify profitable markets. Understanding these trends helps hosts optimize pricing strategies and choose lucrative destinations.

about 20 hours ago85
Airbnb offers $750 incentive for some Ga. hosts during FIFA World Cup - WRDW

Airbnb is offering a $750 incentive for some hosts in Georgia during the FIFA World Cup, potentially boosting occupancy and profitability. This program seeks to capitalize on increased demand from the international event, offering financial benefits to participating hosts. Learn how to qualify and leverage this incentive for your STR.

2 days agoGeorgia85

Curated by Learn STR by GoStudioM