Bidding Wars and Why Investors Get Fooled By “Affordable” Markets

2 months agoScore: 78
Pricing & Profitability
Market Research
Profitability
Pricing Strategy
Investors

Summary

This article warns against bidding wars in real estate, highlighting that buyers often overpay and experience lower returns. It identifies markets prone to bidding wars and offers strategies for navigating them, emphasizing the importance of setting a maximum allowable offer (MAO) and knowing when to walk away.

Key Insights

  • The top 15 metros are expected to see price increases between August 2025 and August 2026, which will likely lead to bidding wars. Specific cities are listed that are expected to increase in value.
  • Homebuyers who win bidding wars overpay by an average of 8.2% and experience weaker returns over time.
  • Winners of bidding wars had annual returns 1.3% lower than comparable investors who stayed out of the fray.
  • Buyers who paid above asking price had higher default rates—1.9% above average.

Action Items

  • If considering a bidding war, consider waiving inspections and contingencies, giving your offer an expiration date, and remaining flexible on the closing date.
    Effort: low
    Impact: medium
  • Stick to your MAO (Maximum Allowable Offer) formula when evaluating a property.
    Effort: low
    Impact: medium
  • Be prepared to walk away from a bidding war if the property can't pay for itself (factoring in all expenses).
    Effort: low
    Impact: medium

Watch Out For

  • Overpaying for a property in a bidding war can lead to lower returns, higher default rates and financial strain.

Related News

KB Home bets on built-to-order strategy amid a spec-heavy market

KB Home is shifting its focus to a built-to-order (BTO) strategy, aiming for higher margins in a challenging market. Hosts should pay attention to this trend as it may impact competition and pricing in their local markets, especially if private builders react to the changes.

1 day ago75
An Overview of Dynamic Pricing for Hosts [+5 Tools Included]

An Overview of Dynamic Pricing for Hosts [+5 Tools Included]

This article discusses dynamic pricing for short-term rentals, explaining how it works to optimize revenue and occupancy by adjusting rates based on market conditions. Hosts should consider implementing dynamic pricing, using tools that automatically adjust rates, to stay competitive and maximize profits.

1 day ago85

United Real Estate CEO Dan Duffy on the roadmap for competitive advantage

This article highlights the importance of data and AI in gaining a competitive edge in the 2026 housing market, emphasizing that hosts who prioritize data-driven decisions and adapt to market changes will thrive. Hosts should focus on leveraging data and AI to make informed decisions about their STR business to capture market share.

1 day ago75

Foreclosure Starts Fall 7.6% Nationally, But These Key Counties Show Rising Distress

Foreclosure starts are down nationally, but certain counties are seeing a rise in early-stage filings, which can indicate future pre-foreclosure opportunities. Hosts in Florida, California, Ohio, North Carolina, and Texas should monitor county-level data to anticipate potential distressed property sales and consider how this might affect their local markets.

1 day ago75